Brown Sugar Pineapple Whiskey Sour

Get into this spirit-forward whiskey cocktail with homemade brown sugar syrup that perfectly balances strong, sweet, and smooth with just three ingredients!

I developed this magical, tropical whiskey drink to celebrate my birthday and it's a mouthful in the very best way. But it's easy to make and even easier to drink. Let's get into the fabulous details!

And if you enjoy this recipe, you'll also love my White Hennessy Pineapple Daiquiri.

What does it taste like?

If you like whiskey and pineapple juice, allow me to upgrade you with juicy, fruity pineapple flavor and the subtle warmth of ginger. And the brown sugar adds a note of sweet caramelized fruit but this ain't no pineapple upside down cake shot.

Nor is it a cloying, sugary "girly" drink (whatever that means). Just smooth, lightly sweet, and potent. The whiskey sour recipe with pineapple is also sometimes called a Hawaiian sour but tastes more like a pineapple whiskey smash, to me.

What You'll Need for this Recipe

This pineapple whiskey cocktail calls for the basic components of a flavored whiskey sour without egg white. Here's what to add to your list:

Whiskey is, of course, the main attraction here. Use your favorite whiskey that you would enjoy sipping neat because the flavor comes through. Scotch, Bourbon, Canadian--any kind of whiskey works.

Lemon Juice fresh squeezed from a lemon is best here but concentrated lemon juice will work in a pinch. Lime juice is also a good backup option.

Pineapple Brown Sugar Simple Syrup is what really turns this into a whisky drink that's strong and fruity. Don't skip it.

Check out the recipe card below for full ingredients list, measurements, and step-by-step instructions!

Which whiskey to use for this whiskey sour?

This is a whiskey drinker's cocktail and made to be sipped and savored--hence the name. The flavor of the spirit comes through so be sure to use your favorite whiskey expression. Since developing this recipe using Uncle Nearest 1856 premium whiskey, I've tested it with several different whiskies and can tell you that quality makes all the difference.

Check out my Hibiscus Hot Toddy made with Uncle Nearest 1884!

Tips & Tools

Grab a cocktail shaker and a jigger. If you don't have a jigger, you can use a shot glass as a good substitute. And if you're using fresh lemon (highly recommended), you'll also need a cutting board and sharp knife.

Can I make this recipe in advance? Yes, you can make the cocktail ahead of time. Just reserve the ice until it's time to enjoy.

More Favorite Whiskey Cocktails

Preparing the Tropical Brown Sugar Syrup

The only cooking involved in this recipe is making the brown sugar syrup, which I recommend making in advance to have on hand for multiple rounds!

Combine equal parts brown sugar and pineapple juice, plus fresh ginger and pineapple over heat and cook down just as you would regular simple syrup.

My Brown Sugar Pineapple Simple Syrup actually works in a variety of cocktail recipes.

How to Serve

This is a simple drink so don't hesitate to be a little extra with the presentation, especially if you're serving it as a birthday cocktail. Serve over rocks ice, which is the name for a large single ice cube traditionally used in spirit forward drinks or liquor on the rocks.

These geometric rocks glasses are the perfect vessel because they not only look fun and interesting, they perch the rocks ice perfectly in the top half of the drink. Finish with a pineapple frond--that's a leaf from the crown--and sip away.

Can I batch this whiskey sour drink? Absolutely. It wouldn't be a birthday without drinks for a crowd! Combine 2 cups of whiskey, 1 ½ cup of the syrup, and ½ cup lemon juice over ice to serve up to eight people.

More Boozy Pineapple Recipes

Dark Pineapple Mojito

Pineapple Upside Down Rum Cake

Spicy Pineapple Jalapeño Mimosas

Let me know how you like this brown sugar whiskey cocktail in the comments below. And sharing is caring so be sure to pin this recipe on Pinterest. Thanks for reading!

Brown Sugar Pineapple Whiskey Sour Cocktail Recipe